Thursday, June 26, 2014

Definitely NOT a Straight Line

But that doesn't mean we are going around in circles either! Enjoyed reading the many comments you made in the two Moodle forums for week #1, commenting about the progressive schools you looked at and then the initial reading in HH Jacobs' Curriculum 21. Jacobs doesn't hold back and that is why I like her book so much. She lays out essential issues and ideas at every turn of the page.

Public Domain CCO
Determining what is important in curriculum development, figuring out how to devise (or revise) curriculum, and reconciling what we have as "curriculum" in schools with what we think we should have are complex issues and processes. We will study these and similar ideas from many different points of view in the next few weeks. But there is definitely not anything resembling a straight line in curriculum development. Lots of U-turns, cycling back, and covering what seems like old ground.

Having read every post and response in Moodle (at least up to this morning), here are several responses from what you all said...and several questions for further study.

1. One of the biggest inhibitors to improvement (notice I didn't say "change") in schools is the traditional model of schooling—with its class periods, bells, hall passes, separate subjects, teacher-directed instruction, reliance on testing—that virtually everyone in the U.S. in the last 100+ years has experienced. When, why, and how did what we all know as "school" become THE way that every school must be? Is there research to support the traditional structures that define most schools as we know them? Are test scores higher in traditional schools? Do students there learn more? (Because this has become the default, the fall-back model on which any type of improvement is judged.)

2. I read lots of your comments with such descriptors as—hands-on, solving real-world problems, Expeditionary Learning, place-based curriculum and teaching, service learning, global focus, and many more. Comments suggesting a different curriculum and a different way of learning than many schools currently pursue. Why is that?

3. Do we really need to talk about technology and learning as if they were/are two separate things? Is there any question that every school should have the tools needed for students to learn?

4. Comment—the schools you read about...KIPP, North Haven, King MS and Casco Bay HS and others all shared one thing in common, I believe. They all had a vision, mission, and plan for getting there. The visions and the ways of operating were different across schools, but they had decided what they were all about and they worked to that end. Not unlike what we try to do as teachers with our students in our own classrooms.

5. Form follows function. Form follows function. Form follows function! Curriculum must come first before we decide how the school will operate, yet that is the exact opposite of what schools typically do. We have a school structure that puts students into groups, sets the time for instruction, decides how the day will be sub-divided, and so on. Why do we set all of these things before we decide what we want our students to learn?

 And, one more thing...As I sat down to write this post, I just finished listening to a fascinating podcast by Amanda Ripley talking with Dan Pink about her latest book, The Smartest Kids in the World and How They Got That Way.  Ripley studied students from Finland, Poland, and South Korea, including American kids who went to each of these countries. You'll be surprised what she says about schools, learning, and the educational systems in these countries.  Since you will be doing a comparative education study of another country's educational system in a couple of weeks, this may be the first step.

Wednesday, June 4, 2014

Welcome to EDC 533 and a little bit about me

Welcome to EDC 533 —Dynamics of the Curriculum. I love teaching this class and I love  studying the issues, concepts, and skills of curriculum development, planning, and implementation with teachers at all levels. As I write this, most of you are looking hopefully to the end of the school year in another week to 10 days. When all you want is a quiet place to sit down with no one asking you questions, you are about to embark on a (another?) graduate course! Amazing...and welcome aboard. It is my job to make this class well worth your while and I take that responsibility very seriously.

If you want to know a little about me, skip down to last year's June 2013 post. Here is a short update for this year...

Late last August I found that a good friend and colleague would be undergoing chemotherapy and radiation treatments during the school year. I volunteered to be her full-time substitute for as long as she needed me and that turned out to be from the beginning of school in September to early February. What a ride it was! I was the third teacher on a two-teacher team working with 42 eighth graders in an integrated curriculum. I even tried to teach math! After 29 years I was back as a full-time middle school teacher. A terrific experience for me and I hope for the students as well. If you are interested in reading a short piece on my 8th grade teaching experience this year, click here. Of course, the best part is that my friend is doing very well and has been back in her classroom since February.

A major change at home this year was that my wife, Connie, and I became first-time grandparents to granddaughter Castine, who is now five and one half months old. Of course we are having a ball watching her grow and develop.

Finally, along with my tech-director son and two good friends/colleagues, I have started an entrepreneurial venture called BoomerTECH Adventures. We will offer four-day retreats for baby boomers who want to travel to Maine and learn something about technology while they are here. Since March I have been very busy building a website, learning about using social media, planning the curriculum, and marketing our retreats. Interesting and fun work!

Ed picking blueberries for his morning cereal

Friday, August 2, 2013

Will I Know It When I See It?

 I spent a terrific day yesterday at the Kieve-Wavus Educator's Conference on Damariscotta Lake (ME) with some bright, thoughtful, and committed people. A sunny day in a gorgeous setting that fed our bodies and souls, with folks who have some of the same interests I have in progressive education.

Conference participants are spending several days devoted to "better understanding the culture, experience, design, and practice of student-driven education."


As you have already inferred, we were not there to talk about aligning the Common Core State Standards to curricula already written. Instead, we spent much time studying curriculum integration, experiential education, project-based and problem-based learning, and many other forms of curriculum design that start with the needs and interests of students...not teachers.

Unfortunately, I wasn't able to participate on day two so like any (former) professor I'm using this blog to do two things—get in another two cents worth on this exciting approach to learning AND also give my EDC 533 students (graduate class in curriculum) another take on curriculum design possibilities.

Here are three issues that are critical to this kind of work:

1. Part of the problem with talking about this type of learning is that there are so many different terms (see paragraph three above). We also talk about democratic classrooms, negotiated curriculum, hands-on learning, expeditionary learning, and on and on and on. When asked, many teachers indicate that they do this kind of work—here are still more terms— interdisciplinary, multidisciplinary, crossdisciplinary, integrated, or integrative. The important point is that while some casual and infrequent stabs at interdisciplinary connections might be considered a good start on the way to a fuller student-driven experience, too often the interdisciplinary unit on turtles or chocolate BECOMES the curriculum event for the term or year.  We need to aim higher for truly authentic, integrative experiences where students are involved in studying real problems, connecting with experts around the globe, and making connections across disciplines.

2. Curriculum integration involves significant student involvement (as we did yesterday with the focusing questions). Themes eventually arise out of these world and self questions that become the focus for the entire class, with significant opportunities, of course, for individual study and reflection. In addition to student involvement in setting the questions, the traditional disciplines are critical. Because of the pervasiveness of the separate subject approach (do we learn in any other aspect of our lives by studying only isolated bits and pieces as we do in schools?) a common critique of curriculum integration is that the disciplines are devalued. Not true. Knowledge plays a key role in any integrative study, albeit in a very different form. In fact, the depth and breadth of study in various disciplines is most often greater than the study of school "subjects".

3. Hmmm...the technology piece. Interesting discussion about this yesterday. Ok, here's the thing. I love technology for what it can do for me. Access to the Interwebs (as Thomas says!) allows me to rig my sailboat every year, fix my refrigerator's icemaker, and it will soon teach me to learn to play the Djembe (I hope). Honestly, I don't see how we can learn in 2013 without every student having the tools of learning and to me that includes a device with Internet access. And this is definitely not about teaching kids to learn to use spreadsheets and MS WORD. It is most definitely about access to information and as we learned yesterday afternoon, knowing how to collect and use data. All of this has to be balanced with learning about the natural world and for heaven's sake knowing when to leave the devices home and turned off!

This final comment falls into the structures of schools that promote or inhibit learning. If I were still teaching middle or high school, our classroom would contain some standing desks, several exercise bikes, a treadmill or two, several banks of carrels, and some comfortable seating as well.  And I would have large blocks of uninterrupted time for learning, in room working lunches, breaks when we need them...And yes, I am very serious about this.

My new Kieve-Wavus friends...please feel free to comment here with any EDC 533 students as well.


Wednesday, July 24, 2013

A Clash of Cultures—What to Compare?

Chisuma School near Victoria Falls, Zimbabwe
Last week you were immersed in studying the educational system of a country somewhere in the world. I've started reading/viewing/listening to your reports and enjoy learning about these very different views of education. Sometimes we forget the our system in the U.S. is not the one that everyone uses.

On our recent trip to Africa we visited the Chisuma School, a small, rural school just outside Victoria Falls, Zimbabwe. Victoria Falls is a tourist area with visitors from around the globe there to see one of the seven natural wonders of the world.

We arrived in the afternoon to find 75 of the school's elementary students outside waiting to greet us. Various grade level groups welcomed us with poems, songs, and performances. All of the students  walk to school, some several miles each way. Parents pay $10/term for each student and even at that modest cost, many students need help with the tuition.

This elementary school has a special and very dedicated group of high school students who live too far from the local high school to attend that school...so they attend this school closer to their homes. In one room at least 55 students were crowded together in a hot, stuffy room with few textbooks available. The teacher wrote the lessons on the chalkboard. But still, these students are committed to their studies and realize that education is their pathway to a better life.

Education in Zimbabwe has suffered terribly as has the entire country during the economic crisis of the last 15 years. Once known as the breadbasket of southern Africa, with one of the highest literacy rates in Africa, the country now has an 80% unemployment rate.

While in 1980 an average of six dollars was allocated per pupil, in 2009 this amount had dropped to $.70 per pupil. As a result, the pupil-textbook ratio in urban schools has dropped to one textbook for every 10 pupils while in rural schools there is only one textbook available for every 40 pupils. The deterioration of the education system and the political tensions in the country have also caused an exodus of teachers.

The Zimbabwe Teachers Association (ZIMTA)  estimates that in the past decade more than 45,000 teachers have left the country. A recent estimate indicated that 35% of the teacher posts in primary education and 33% in secondary education were vacant. 

We have so much and they have so little.



Tuesday, July 9, 2013

What I did on my summer vacation

Hwange National Park
July 7, 2013. Monday morning, 3 am Eastern time. 

Sunrise on the horizon three hours out from our JFK destination. This 16 hour flight began at 9 pm in Johannesburg, South Africa last night  and we'll arrive in NYC at 6:15 am, wait several hours for our daughter and son-in-law to arrive from their flight through London, jump in the car and drive 8 hours to Orono.  A relaxing day or two!

Our first four days in Zimbabwe were on safari in Hwange National Park in the northwest part of the country. Two hours into the bush by an open air Land Rover at no more than 30 miles an hour. Absolutely incredible. We saw hundreds of elephants, giraffe, buffalo, birds of all types, warthogs, ostrich, kudu, Impala, baboons, crocodile, zebra...and yes, several lions. Our last morning in camp we woke up to a lioness not more than 50 yards from our lodge. Because elephants were everywhere we could hear them at night rubbing up against our buildings, eating the vegetation, and trumpeting frequently. In the dry season they come right down to the small swimming pool to drink and actually empty it every night.

The last half of our holiday was spent moving around a bit more. We stayed in Victoria Falls to see the falls (one of the 7 natural wonders of the world). It makes Niagara Falls look like the Kenduskeag Stream. We drove into neighboring Botswana to overnight and take a great cruise on the Chobe River where we saw many hippos and two groups of elephants swim across the river; a spectacular sight with the baby elephants being towed by their mamas. We stayed away from the crocodiles!

The last day we spent in Johannesburg and Soweto touring and visiting two museums including the Apartheid Museum, a sobering and astonishing experience. I had no idea how great a role education played in this critical period of history. The curriculum that the Afrikans imposed on the native population caused the protests that led to eventually overthrowing apartheid. The power of the curriculum.

Many, many highlights, but the absolute best part of this experience was the fact that our group of ten was our family—our four adult children and their spouses. What a great opportunity to spend that much time with each other and share these amazing experiences.

And not insignificantly, thanks to all of you students in EDC 533 who were patient with my absence. My ability to stay connected while in Africa was about what I expected, not much access. A bit of email, but connecting to Moodle didn't happen. I promise to get caught up in the next couple of days.

Now, back to EDC 533 and the excellent work you all are doing.

Monday, June 17, 2013

 Welcome to EDC 533...summer 2013!

A little bit about me...

I have had three fantastic years since my "retirement" in August 2010 from a 25-year career as professor of middle level education at the University of Maine.  We prefer the term "refocus" in our house.

This year I continued my work with schools on digital citizenship. With colleagues, produced an online, multi-part series on Digital Footprint and Web Presence for middle and high school students (and their parents and teachers); currently developing a six-hour, online, professional development course for educational leaders on parent/community partnerships. My other area of interest is Student Technology Teams. I assisted Warsaw Middle School this year as they started their own student technology team thanks to a grant from Maine Community Foundation. Presented at several conferences on both digital citizenship and student technology teams. Just completed an article about starting student technology teams.

Before UMaine, I taught high school English and middle school language arts in Rochester, NY and Greeley, CO for 12 years. Began my career as a high school teacher but really found my niche with middle school. (My wife says my affinity for middle school occurred because my own development was arrested about 7th grade. Hmmm...I thought that was a compliment!) I loved teaching middle school...the hardest job I ever had and the most rewarding in many ways! But those of you in the classroom already know that.

Connie (my wife) is the founder and director of Operation Breaking Stereotypes, a non-profit that brings together students from Maine and NYC high schools to learn about each others' worlds. We have four adult "children"...one high school English/musical theater teacher in Maine, a high school technology integrator in Minnesota, an urban planner in Boston, and a historic preservationist in NYC.

I run, swim, play tennis, ski, sail...and spend July and August at camp...enjoying Maine.

Monday, July 9, 2012

What does it mean to be a learner and a teacher in the 21st century?

 Two thought provoking articles from both sides of the desk.  

What do you think of these portrayals of students and teachers?

"Snapshot of a modern learner" by Mike Fisher
http://smartblogs.com/education/2012/06/29/snapshot-modern-learner/


"What is a 21st-century teacher?" by Josh Stumpenhorst
http://smartblogs.com/education/2012/06/22/what-21st-century-teacher/

Thursday, June 30, 2011

Some not-so-random curriculum questions

What do you think about some of these questions, all generated from your comments and discussion thus far in blogs and forums?

1. What does it mean to involve our students in curriculum development? How much should they be involved?

2. Is the concept of scope and sequence in curriculum a valid concept in 2011. Or does technology make scope and sequence outdated?

3. Why are subjects the primary organizing framework for curriculum at the K-12 level? Who decided that the subjects we teach are the ones our students should know?

4. Why does the K-12 curriculum give so little attention to the issues that our students are interested in?

5.  If you had to describe the elementary, middle level, or high school curriculum—what you see as the essential learnings at that level— what would you say?

6. What are two other ways to organize the curriculum other than the traditional separate subjects? What does each look like?

7. HH Jacobs does think of teachers as the drivers of curriculum improvement. Should teachers be the movers and shakers of curriculum?

8. If we asked our students to suggest what they would like to learn, what would they say...at different levels?

Thanks for all of these great questions. I look forward to answering them with you!

Tuesday, March 15, 2011

Another Dan Pink book to ponder

A couple of years ago at the National Middle School Association annual conference Dan Pink was a keynote speaker talking about his then best-seller, A Whole New Mind (AWNM).  Although I had read and used AWNM in a technology and learning class for several semesters, I was pleased to hear Pink (and later meet him) and to think about the six senses, the heart of the book, that Pink describes in depth.

As an educator, I always try to apply his work to schools and students and finding such applications is not difficult at all...just as in Drive.  Here are several key points that Pink makes in AWNM.

1. Explore new metrics—measure more than IQ which gets lots of play in schools, but doesn't begin to include the full range of intelligences. With the emphasis on NCLB and standardized testing for so long, schools are struggling to stay focused on a wider range of expectations beyond achievement. Whatever happened to "the whole child" that we used to talk about?

2. Get real about STEM—of course math and science and engineering are important, but so are the arts, literature, foreign languages, physical education and many other areas that have traditionally been part of the K-12 curriculum, but now receive less time and emphasis. Interesting since STEM is getting more and more attention and just about everything else less and less.

3. Re-think motivation. Stress doesn't work as an incentive, nor fear, nor many of the things that we use as motivators in schools. Instead the big three—autonomy, mastery, and purpose—are the elements we should focus on. Think about what motivates us as adults. Don't we want to respond to these three critical elements?

4. More forest, less terrarium—more need for the big picture; also, we need to have a larger view when dealing with problems. Time to consider alternatives, like Google's notion of allowing employees to spend 20% of their work time on projects they are interested in. You read about FedEx time in Drive. What do you think about teachers and administrators having this kind of time to do this type of work?

5. Finally, infuse the arts throughout the curriculum. No question how important this is and how much more should be said about it.

For those of you who are reading  A Whole New Mind as your podcast book, I hope this hasn't given away too much! Another thoughtful read.

Friday, February 18, 2011

Thinking about curriculum

Idea #1—The Dewey Decimal System, short story unit, photosynthesis, long division. These were a few of the opening of school units in various subjects and grades during my stellar K-12 career. Memorable? Nope. Engaging as initial units at the beginning of a new school year? Not really. Did they contain answers to questions that I had asked. Are you kidding? John Arnold, a university colleague once commented, "The middle school curriculum consists too much of giving our students answers to questions they never ask." A very powerful idea. He was right...and this idea applies to elementary and high schools as well, I'm sure. Children, young adolescents, and older adolescents have many interests, but those interests are not necessarily what the curriculum dictates when we don't give them time to ask and answer questions they have about their lives and the world.

Idea #2—For three weeks we have been reading about a variety of innovative schools and programs that sometimes look very different from the typical schools we all know. The question I wonder about is why we have so few examples of schools doing other than the traditional things we all know? Yes, there are a number of teachers doing other things and occasionally an entire school (King MS and expeditionary learning), but typically most schools have one model that all students must fit into. Why is that? Why can't any school try out different ideas to meet the needs of students (first), but also use the strengths of their teachers. A short example...why can't high schools or middle schools use different ways of organizing students and teachers...some self-contained, different sized teams, maybe even a team that crosses grade levels...all in the same school? Or, a combination of F2F and blended classes instead of all F2F?

Idea #3—Some thought-provoking ideas from all of you in our shared Google Doc in week 5 and our discussions about what we expect from young adolescents by the end of middle school. (Again, this list applies to elementary and high school students as well, don't you think?) Here are some of the ideas...limited because of space. Our middle schooler will be...self-reliant, a risk-taker, open minded, one who accepts responsibility, is independent and can work and think independently, learns from her/his mistakes, self-sufficient. Others said that schools should be places where students are motivated to continue to learn on their own; places that are fun, safe, and experimental, allowing students to explore their own possibilities; where education is connected to doing, and; where students learn empathy for one another. Lots more, but this is an excellent start, don't you think?

Wednesday, February 2, 2011

Don't throw these away

We are studying so many different ideas in EDC 533, reading critiques about what doesn't work, and trying to balance the old and the new. I honestly believe that one of the biggest barriers to improving schools as we know them...is that we know them so well. When anyone makes a suggestion about doing something different, the immediate reaction is to back up (and almost always defensively) and dig our heels in. The assumption that we make in this situation that what we were doing was wrong, ineffective, or harmful.


We know there are all kinds of helpful and positive practices whose value should continue. Here are several of the things that I think work well in classrooms and schools...and why. Remember, you read it here first.


1. We will continue to need gathering places for teachers and students (let's call them schools) for the opportunities for human connections. Between students and students; teachers and teachers, and; students and teachers. We need to learn from each other because with more and more technology, we need what Alvin Toffler called, "High tech, high touch." In this digital age we need more opportunities for human beings to work together...one of the most critical skills of the future.


2. A good part of learning is developing a sense of community. Having shared experiences. As good as Skype and other video conferencing systems are...they do not take the place of all face-to-face interactions. We need to learn from each other and we need to have an audience for our work that is safe, respectful, and welcoming.


3. Finally, nothing will take the place of a caring, committed, knowledgeable teacher who has taught her students to think deeply. Especially from pre-K through 8th or 9th grade, we need to have teachers who facilitate the learning of her charges...and even beyond that age level. Guiding, prodding, suggesting, encouraging...are only the beginning of what a good teacher does to her students.


These turned out to be more big picture items that I first anticipated, but I am sure that grammar, long division, and knowing how photosynthesis works is not what we will want to keep around for 21st century school...at least not in the form they are in today.


But, maybe, just maybe, there is something else I should have mentioned here. If so, I will be back!

Tuesday, February 1, 2011

Why don't they teach us more about technology (and learning)?

"I would use more technology in my classroom, but my school/district doesn't provide enough training for me to learn how to use all the tools available to us."

Have you heard that before?

Do you believe it?

This post came from my response in a recent Moodle forum and frankly, it was too good not to share more widely (he says modestly!).

Jon D. hit the nail directly on the head in his response...and I pick up from there. When MLTI started in 2002 or so, Bette Manchester and crew did an outstanding job of "mass educating" middle level teachers about the laptops, how they worked, and most importantly, how they could be used by students and teachers as learning tools. Before giving out brand-new laptops to every 7th and 8th grade teacher and student in Maine, they needed to have a massive professional development program like never seen before. The PD had to be thoughtful, engaging, multifaceted, and it had to be done fast! Preparing for initial MLTI implementation had to be done at that time and in that way and ultimately it was very successful. But as Jon notes, there is no way that we can provide personalized "service" to everyone. Mass education just doesn't work anymore (and maybe that goes for our work with our students as well)!

There is a reason why manuals that used to be book size are now on 3 x 5 inch cards; in addition, many tutorials, podcasts, and written explanations are readily available online. Once past a certain level of "technology savvy-ness", we simply need to spend some time with a new device or tool (like VoiceThread) and learn how to use it. Perhaps a major problem is that we don't take time to learn something by playing with it.

Let's deal with the elephant in the room. Why don't we use the expertise/knowledge of our students? Why doesn't every Maine school have an iTeam with tech-learning savvy kids who can not only set up and fix the machines...but more importantly, can help us figure out how to use them to learn? Let's take this even further. I suggest that every elementary, middle and high school have an iTeam whose members are knowledgeable about how the technology works, how it can be used to help students and teacher learn, but are also knowledgeable about using it safely, responsibly, and ethically. Call this digital citizenship if you like. And then we teach every student and teacher in the school how to use digital media in this responsible way. Possible...of course! Probable...only if we have the will to make it happen.

So, whose responsibility is it for us to learn more about technology and learning...and why aren't we using the expertise of our students who are willing and eager to help us learn this stuff?

Tuesday, January 18, 2011

The yellow brick (curriculum) road

I didn't have a clue...when I participated in my first curriculum development experience. Still a graduate student in an M.A.T. program, I was preparing to do my internship (student teaching) in a school with no full-time English teachers. My fellow interns and I were the English Department and we inherited absolutely nothing in the way of curriculum—except the kids themselves and some used books. Zero, zip, zilch in the curriculum department. And this was 25 years before anyone even started talking about the standards movement! I'm not sure how effective we were with those kids that year, but we certainly learned a lot about what did and did not work in curriculum development. In a word...know your clientele!

Experience number two occurred in my first two years of teaching in a large, suburban high school (2200 students in grades 10-12) where I had a wonderful experience designing all kinds of interesting curricula for a "phased elective program" that was all the rage then. English and social studies departments in particular were building six-week elective courses on all kinds of high interest topics. Remember, this was 1971-1973 and high schools were in the "if we build it they will come" mode. In this progressive era, I taught film, film-making, consumer reading, science fiction, and a host of other topics that WE thought would be engaging for our students. This was an interesting time for curriculum development and was followed shortly by the usual cycle...back-to-basics.

During the next 10 years, I had almost total free-rein in developing curriculum for my middle school and high school classes; also, many opportunities to work on a new school program for both levels. Heady times...exciting...and very challenging.

What did I learn from all of this? Lessons learned will be described in a subsequent post.

Sunday, March 14, 2010

What a week!

It’s been an interesting week…proposed national standards in English and math were released on Wednesday while the cover of Newsweek magazine suggested that firing teachers was the way to "save" education in the U.S.

Sounds like it's time to call the psychiatrist! Middle school guru, John Lounsbury, suggests that when we are faced with vexing curriculum issues, we should call the psychiatrist rather than the curriculum coordinator. Why? Because many of the issues that pop up as curriculum related are really about our inability to think about things in new ways.

Keeping the old models as Heidi Hayes Jacobs described in her new book, Curriculum 21...structures like schedules, grouping patterns of both students and teachers, and how we use space and time. Most high schools, for example, use a traditional class schedule that dictates what and how any content will be delivered. In similar fashion, why don't more schools (including middle schools!) use the middle school team as their model for organizing professionals?

Time to call the psychiatrist...to get us to think about more than adding or dropping a course...about more than changing the length of class periods...about more than typing papers on computers instead of typewriters...and calling that curriculum development.

In the meantime, take a look at the proposed national standards linked above to see what you think, particularly about the standards in your area of expertise. And take a look at the Newsweek article as well...and some of the lively discussion that is taking place about it online.

Wednesday, February 24, 2010

What I Learned About Curriculum from 17 High School Students This Week

For the second year during the February school break, my wife and I accompanied area high school students to help rebuild New Orleans. This year we took 17 students from Old Town and Orono High Schools (and one each from Bangor HS and Hampden Academy) to help rebuild two houses under the auspices of the St. Bernard Project in St. Bernard Parish (southeast New Orleans).

On one house, we began the tedious but important work of "mold remediation" where for a day and a half, 14 of us scrubbed the invisible mold spores from every inch of the studs, rafters, walls, and beams. Wearing respirators we scrubbed our hearts out...not glamorous work, but critical in the 8-12 week cycle of rebuilding a Katrina-damaged home. Later in the week, all 22 of us spent a day out in the country on the bayou, replanting Cypress and Oak trees to provide wind cover and prevent erosion, replacing the trees killed by the flooding.

Spending one week with 17 high school students is quite the experience and I loved (nearly) every minute of it. (Ok, except for the last two hours in the van listening to hip hop on the way home from Logan Airport...but that was my problem!) As I reflected on what I learned by this year's experience I couldn't help but see the connection with EDC 533. Here is what I learned about how adolescents learn and what is important to them. Do you see a connection to our discussions about curriculum and learning? What do these issues have to do with what our curriculum is and how we make it work?

• Adolescents want to do things—physical things...and they want to do them now.  No one minded steel-brushing mold off every surface of a house because they knew how important this first step was in rebuilding a house for someone who didn't have one. And also, because they were working side-by-side with their friends.

• Teenagers want to change the world and they want to do that now too. Not when they are older...they recognize how much they can accomplish and they are anxious to get on with it. Conversely, they have too much tolerance for wasting their time, when they could be doing something useful.

• Adults are absolutely critical in the lives of young people—as role models, mentors, friends, and yes, as adults. Kids need people to fulfill parental roles (whether mom and dad or other caregivers), but they also need opportunities to learn from other caring adults.

• Young adults are amazingly tolerant and understanding of others. They are empathetic and caring about the life situations of others.

• And, of course, they are just plain fun to be around!

Sunday, February 7, 2010

How hidden is the hidden curriculum?

In the late '50s (that would be the 1950s, thank you) I attended a new neighborhood elementary school in my hometown of Tecumseh, Michigan.  Small town America in the 1950s. School was nearby and we walked our rode our bikes; we went home for lunch and someone was there to make it for us; and we went home after school, changed our clothes and went out to play with friends until we were called in for supper. It sounds a little like an old episode of Ozzie and Harriet (please look it up if you don't know what this show was).

School was predictable and engaging enough, I suppose. I don't remember much about the curriculum of the elementary years outside of several soundbites that even 50 years later are vivid: Making Easter baskets in 4th grade; spelling bees in grade 4 and higher; naps in kindergarten. That's about it, but I do remember exactly what I learned in fifth and sixth grades.

In fifth grade, my teacher, Mr. W. was a veteran. While I must have learned any number of other things, what I remember most about fifth grade was his many war stories...which he told us every day. The single most vivid recollection of sixth grade was the time our entire class had to hand write, copy really, a paragraph about not acting up and getting in trouble when our teacher was out of the classroom. Mrs. G, our teacher, thought she was teaching us a great lesson by making us copy that paragraph 50 times...and she did. But after the numbness in my fingers wore off, I realized that my classmates and I did learn a life's lesson...but sadly, not the one Mrs. G. intended. The lesson we learned was that you shouldn't tell someone to do one thing and then not model that behavior in your own life. Why did we learn that lesson? Because as a teaching principal Mrs. G. was frequently out of our classroom seeing to her principal duties, leaving us, her sixth grade class, to our own devices. Sometimes that worked...but often it did not. If I had asked either Mr. W. or Mrs. G. what they intended to teach us those two years, I'm certain the lessons we learned were not what they intended. The "hidden" curriculum strikes again.

When I think about all the things kids learn in school...as well as how hard teachers work to have them learn those things, I wonder why the hidden curriculum is so strong and powerful. Is it because we don't often consider the unintended consequences of what we don't explicitly teach or because we ignore the real lessons right in front of us. For example, all the relationship issues that exist in an institution like school where so many different people co-exist. How can there not be a number of lessons learned there? This is the heart of the "hidden" curriculum, I believe.

And our students are watching us every step of the way...seeing how adults treat each other; how some teachers treat certain students with less care and respect than they deserve; how some groups (athletes, honor students, students from affluent families) receive favored or special treatment.

What other examples of the hidden curriculum should we be aware of? And how can we move it from hidden to a legitimate part of the curriculum?

Wednesday, January 13, 2010

Curriculum Questions

Which of these make sense to you?

• Work on a project for 43 minutes, scramble to put it away, and move to a different room to start another project (or listen to someone else talk about a totally different topic)...and continue to do that all day.

• Work with up to 10 different experts each and every day one 10 different topics...yet, these experts never (or rarely) talk to each other about the things they know in common.

• Not have access to the tools you need to do the job...if you are building something, you don't have a hammer, saw, and measures. If you are writing something, you may have a pencil, but you don't have a computer.

You get the picture. Schools have many regularities—the way they are organized...six hours each day with a series of random contacts between teachers and students. Connections among classes are the exception rather than the rule (and this is true at the elementary school more and more...just as it always has been at the middle and high school levels).

Other regularities include a school year of approximately nine months and an extended summer break.

Several questions for you to think about?
√ Do these common expectations or commonly accepted ways of "doing school" assist learning or do they hinder learning? Are there better ways to organize schools...at any level?

√ In most schools, the curriculum is organized around separate subjects (and again...more and more so since NCLB...but that is another story!).

√ If someone appointed you principal of the day, what would you do about some of the school regularities we all grew up with and know so well?

Is your school regular?

Sunday, January 10, 2010

One more time around the curriculum

Can our curriculum be student centered AND leave no child behind, posits Gayle Andrews in her excellent curriculum article in the November 2008 issue of Middle School Journal? Gayle talks about the changing context for the original vision of Turning Points 2000 when it was published in 2000...

"In a world increasingly focused on accountability, extensive federal and state legislation, policies, and mandates seem to clutter the educational landscape and obscure and perhaps overshadow the students who should dominate it."

This is the second encounter I've had today with the essential notion of young adolescents as the focal point for middle level education. Imagine that. Maybe we are making some progress...or merely returning "back to the future." Here, in this article, Gayle Andrews makes a critical point about redefining some priorities.

And here is where it gets sticky..."Turning Points 2000 called for integrating curriculum across disciplines, a seemingly problematic suggestion in light of discipline-based standards and high-stakes tests." But, Andrews delivers the clincher when she points out the (curriculum) elephant sitting in the room, "Although disciplines and departments have reigned in schools for more than a century, few could reasonably contend that these structures have led most students to deep understanding in the various subjects." Ouch. Of course they don't, because they are disciplines in departments are organizational conveniences that only give a semblance of order, structure, and yes, learning.

Later, Andrews indicates that if she and co-author, Tony Jackson, were to write Turning Points 2008...they would turn the first recommendation about curriculum "on its head....In a new version, the concerns of young adolescents would be the primary foundation for curriculum, with standards and how students learn best in a close tie for second."

The rest of the article makes a case for returning to integrated curriculum and centering on students as the middle level focus. Among several other important points is the one that Andrews acknowledges..."...the limitations of teaching concepts absent a rich context that students find relevant and meaningful." There is no doubt...and everyone is writing about it...that the current system lacks that rich context because teachers focus on the details within the standards rather than the overarching concepts.

The solution...we must get teachers thinking again about the big picture...and not the details of disciplines and test items. If you haven't read this gem of an article—and it carries a big punch—walk, don't run to secure your copy.

A Whole New Mind

Hearing Dan Pink talk about his work, particularly ideas from his best-seller, A Whole New Mind, at  National Middle School Association's annual conference in Indianapolis in November 2009 was terrific. Although I have read and used AWNM for several semesters, I always pick up new ideas that I haven't seen before as well as ways of thinking about the six senses that Pink describes in depth.

Of course, as an educator, I always try to apply his work to schools and students and finding such applications is not difficult at all. At NMSA he summarized some key points using (to me at any rate) some different language than I had heard his use before. Again, another way to think about these important ideas.

1. Explore new metrics—measure more than IQ which gets lots of play in schools, but doesn't begin to include the full range of intelligences.

2. Get real about STEM—of course math and science and engineering are important, but so are the arts, literature, foreign languages, physical education and many other areas that have traditionally been part of the K-12 curriculum, but now receive less time and emphasis.

3. Re-think motivation—not surprising since Pink has a new book (Drive) on motivation soon to hit the bookstores. Stress doesn't work as an incentive, nor fear, nor many of the things that we use as motivators in schools.

4. More forest, less terrarium—more need for the big picture; also, we need to have a larger view when dealing with problems. Time to consider alternatives, like Google's notion of allowing employees to spend 20% of their work time on projects they are interested in. (Many of the creative aspects of Google have come out of that 20% time.)

5. Finally, infuse the arts throughout the curriculum. No question how important this is.

Suggestion for all, read or re-read Pink's A Whole New Mind.