Wednesday, January 13, 2010

Curriculum Questions

Which of these make sense to you?

• Work on a project for 43 minutes, scramble to put it away, and move to a different room to start another project (or listen to someone else talk about a totally different topic)...and continue to do that all day.

• Work with up to 10 different experts each and every day one 10 different topics...yet, these experts never (or rarely) talk to each other about the things they know in common.

• Not have access to the tools you need to do the job...if you are building something, you don't have a hammer, saw, and measures. If you are writing something, you may have a pencil, but you don't have a computer.

You get the picture. Schools have many regularities—the way they are organized...six hours each day with a series of random contacts between teachers and students. Connections among classes are the exception rather than the rule (and this is true at the elementary school more and more...just as it always has been at the middle and high school levels).

Other regularities include a school year of approximately nine months and an extended summer break.

Several questions for you to think about?
√ Do these common expectations or commonly accepted ways of "doing school" assist learning or do they hinder learning? Are there better ways to organize schools...at any level?

√ In most schools, the curriculum is organized around separate subjects (and again...more and more so since NCLB...but that is another story!).

√ If someone appointed you principal of the day, what would you do about some of the school regularities we all grew up with and know so well?

Is your school regular?

Sunday, January 10, 2010

One more time around the curriculum

Can our curriculum be student centered AND leave no child behind, posits Gayle Andrews in her excellent curriculum article in the November 2008 issue of Middle School Journal? Gayle talks about the changing context for the original vision of Turning Points 2000 when it was published in 2000...

"In a world increasingly focused on accountability, extensive federal and state legislation, policies, and mandates seem to clutter the educational landscape and obscure and perhaps overshadow the students who should dominate it."

This is the second encounter I've had today with the essential notion of young adolescents as the focal point for middle level education. Imagine that. Maybe we are making some progress...or merely returning "back to the future." Here, in this article, Gayle Andrews makes a critical point about redefining some priorities.

And here is where it gets sticky..."Turning Points 2000 called for integrating curriculum across disciplines, a seemingly problematic suggestion in light of discipline-based standards and high-stakes tests." But, Andrews delivers the clincher when she points out the (curriculum) elephant sitting in the room, "Although disciplines and departments have reigned in schools for more than a century, few could reasonably contend that these structures have led most students to deep understanding in the various subjects." Ouch. Of course they don't, because they are disciplines in departments are organizational conveniences that only give a semblance of order, structure, and yes, learning.

Later, Andrews indicates that if she and co-author, Tony Jackson, were to write Turning Points 2008...they would turn the first recommendation about curriculum "on its head....In a new version, the concerns of young adolescents would be the primary foundation for curriculum, with standards and how students learn best in a close tie for second."

The rest of the article makes a case for returning to integrated curriculum and centering on students as the middle level focus. Among several other important points is the one that Andrews acknowledges..."...the limitations of teaching concepts absent a rich context that students find relevant and meaningful." There is no doubt...and everyone is writing about it...that the current system lacks that rich context because teachers focus on the details within the standards rather than the overarching concepts.

The solution...we must get teachers thinking again about the big picture...and not the details of disciplines and test items. If you haven't read this gem of an article—and it carries a big punch—walk, don't run to secure your copy.

A Whole New Mind

Hearing Dan Pink talk about his work, particularly ideas from his best-seller, A Whole New Mind, at  National Middle School Association's annual conference in Indianapolis in November 2009 was terrific. Although I have read and used AWNM for several semesters, I always pick up new ideas that I haven't seen before as well as ways of thinking about the six senses that Pink describes in depth.

Of course, as an educator, I always try to apply his work to schools and students and finding such applications is not difficult at all. At NMSA he summarized some key points using (to me at any rate) some different language than I had heard his use before. Again, another way to think about these important ideas.

1. Explore new metrics—measure more than IQ which gets lots of play in schools, but doesn't begin to include the full range of intelligences.

2. Get real about STEM—of course math and science and engineering are important, but so are the arts, literature, foreign languages, physical education and many other areas that have traditionally been part of the K-12 curriculum, but now receive less time and emphasis.

3. Re-think motivation—not surprising since Pink has a new book (Drive) on motivation soon to hit the bookstores. Stress doesn't work as an incentive, nor fear, nor many of the things that we use as motivators in schools.

4. More forest, less terrarium—more need for the big picture; also, we need to have a larger view when dealing with problems. Time to consider alternatives, like Google's notion of allowing employees to spend 20% of their work time on projects they are interested in. (Many of the creative aspects of Google have come out of that 20% time.)

5. Finally, infuse the arts throughout the curriculum. No question how important this is.

Suggestion for all, read or re-read Pink's A Whole New Mind.